- Indian lawmakers and analysts are underestimating the level of permanent scarring the economy faces due to the effects of income loss for many families, as well as for small and medium-sized businesses, according to JPMorgan’s Jahangir Aziz.
- The economic crisis due to last year’s long blockade to slow the spread of the coronavirus outbreak has disproportionately affected micro, small and medium-sized companies, as well as the informal sector.
- The concern is that, with compromised balance sheets, these companies may not get the loans they need.
Click to expand
A major risk to India’s economic recovery is that millions of families and small businesses may have the credit they need, according to JPMorgan’s chief emerging markets economist.
The government, the central bank and analysts are underestimating the level of permanent scarring that can occur in South Asia’s largest economy as a result of the contraction caused by last year’s pandemic, Jahangir Aziz said on Friday at CNBC’s “Squawk Box Asia.“
Loss of income
The loss of revenue related to the coronavirus pandemic amounts to billions of dollars annually, according to Aziz. “We know that listed companies have not suffered so much, so it has to be SMEs (small and medium-sized companies) and households that have suffered much more,” he said.
This includes workers in the informal sector, such as day laborers and also domestic workers.
“I cannot imagine that, with this type of loss of income, you will not have serious losses on the balance sheets of families and SMEs”, added Aziz.
He explained that much of this has not yet appeared in lenders’ loan books because of the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) debt moratorium last year. To mitigate the economic impact of the blockade, the central bank said last year that creditors were allowed to give borrowers a temporary delay in the monthly payment of loans between March and May. It was then extended until August.
“But the debt moratorium does not solve the problem, it simply pushes the problem into the second half of the year,” said Aziz.
The economic crisis due to last year long blockade to slow the spread of the coronavirus outbreak it disproportionately affected micro, small and medium-sized enterprises, as well as the informal sector.
Millions of jobs have been lost – many of them permanently.
In fact, the rating agency S&P recently said that India faces a permanent loss of around 10% of economic production compared to its pre-pandemic path.
The World Bank in December said informal sector workers did not have access to certain resources – for example, large companies may have access to credit even if they are not profitable. However, access to credit and other forms of social support are not as readily available to those working in the informal sector.
Credit concerns in India
Indian micro, small and medium-sized enterprises contribute about 30% of nominal GDP and the sector is the country’s second largest employer, behind agriculture, according to the central bank.
To support these companies, the RBI introduced emergency credit schemes and implemented policy measures, such as interest rate cuts, a debt service moratorium and loan restructuring package.
According to local media reports, creditors said most of the single restructuring option was relied on for corporate loans and very few for retail loans, implying that people are paying on time or a default crisis may be lurking.
Another concern is that, with deteriorated balance sheets, small and medium-sized businesses may not get the loans they need in the future. That’s because, potentially, lenders may choose to lend only to larger companies that did relatively better during the crisis. Or they can charge smaller companies a higher premium for loans. The financial sector was already battling defaults before the pandemic arrived.
“So one of the main risks I have is that, exactly when we would like credit to increase, there would be a lot of people and SMEs that would not be able to get credit,” said Aziz.
In its half-year Financial Stability Report published in January, the RBI said it expects bad debt to rise to 13.5% in September, almost doubling from the 7.5% seen a year ago. If the situation gets worse, non-performing loans could rise by up to 14.8%, the central bank said.